Post Description
CD1 (set 1):
01 Shine On You Crazy Diamond 11:58
02 Signs Of Life 03:17
03 Learning To Fly 05:22
04 Yet Another Movie 06:17
05 Round And Around 00:49
06 Sorrow 09:38
07 The Dogs Of War 07:19
08 On The Turning Away 08:54
CD2 (set 2 + encore):
01 One Of These Days 06:16
02 Time 05:14
03 On The Run 02:13
04 The Great Gig In The Sky 04:43
05 Wish You Were Here 04:42
06 Us And Them 07:21
07 Money 09:52
08 Another Brick In The Wall (part 2) 05:34
09 Comfortably Numb 08:57
10 One Slip 05:51
11 Run Like Hell 07:24
Total time: 2 hours 1 minute 41 seconds
NOTES:
First of all I must say that for me both post-Waters era live releases are excellent in terms of quality of the music/performance/recording.
But both of them lack the completeness of actually performed material on these tours. So the P.U.L.S.E revision is the pipeline.
2 CD capacity (74 minutes x2) is enough to present the whole set list of these concerts, but unfortunately this opportunity wasn't used.
2 LP record version was understandably shorter. So 8 (!!!) tracks were omitted from longest audio release of this album.
Longest VHS / LD video companion (UK version omits 'Money') is shorter than 2CD set but it features 4 tracks which were omitted from audio version.
In my point of view it was strange decision to cut such key track as SOYCD down to Part I only and add 'Signs Of Life' after that (track of the similar vibe) and 'On The Run' instead of proper songs such as 'Another Brick In The Wall'.
What is really sad that 'Welcome To The Machine' was completely omitted from all versions by unknown reason. As well as 'A New Machine/Terminal Frost' medley from the first set.
So here is my attempt to merge all released material under 'Delicate Sound Of Thunder' title into one expanded set:
1. Shine On You Crazy Diamond (21th August)
Unaltered CD version crossfaded with following track.
Both tracks were merged using soundboard recording of the 21st August show as a reference.
2. Signs Of Life (21th August / composite - edited)
US LD version crossfaded with previous track. See above.
3. Learning To Fly (21th August)
As this track is crossfaded with 'Signs Of Life' on video companion, switch back to CD source was done after the first chorus.
4. Yet Another Movie (21th August / 19th August composite)
Unaltered CD source.
5. Round And Around (21st August / 19th August composite)
As this track and the following one 'Sorrow' unfortunately were crossfaded on CD, but were presented separately on LP version (and performed in concerts) I made a decision to restore the separation using LP source.
So the last 15 seconds of the track is from the LP source. By the way, this track duration on CD is 20 seconds shorter due to this crossfade.
6. Sorrow (23th August - edited)
First 15 seconds of the track is from LP source crossfaded with CD source. By the way the actual length of the song was shortened for CD and even more for LD by editing the guitar solo parts.
7. The Dogs Of War (21st August / 20th August composite - edited intro)
Unaltered CD source.
8. On The Turning Away (21st August - edited)
As versions on CD and LD feature different guitar solo edits of the full length performance, I made a composite of CD and US LD source to create the most complete version of this song.
Now the duration of this track is 55 seconds longer than the CD edit version. Now it's almost complete. I used 21st August show sounboard recording as the reference.
9. One Of These Days (22nd August / 23th August composite - edited)
Unaltered CD source.
10. Time (19th August - edited guitar/roto-toms intro)
Unaltered CD source with the exception of the final chord which is from US LD source. It was made to preserve the original transition into the next track.
It's important to note that video version of this track feature guitar/roto-toms intro from different night.
11. On The Run (??? - edited)
Unaltered US LD source. Date of the used performance is unknown for me by now as I still didn't complete the analysis process. And it's really hard for this track.
12. The Great Gig In The Sky (21st August 1988)
Perfect performance by all the girls. First part is taken from US LD source. Starting with the last drum kick there's a switch into UK LD source.
It was made to preserve the original transition to the next track. US LD has fade in/out after this track caused by the side change. UK LD has side change before this track.
13. Wish You Were Here (23th August 1988)
UK LD source for the intro of the song. Switch to CD source made with the start of the drumming.
14. Us And Them (23rd August / ???)
Unaltered CD source.
15. Money (23th August / 21st August / composite - edited)
Unaltered CD source.
16. Another Brick In The Wall (part 2) (21st August / 19th August composite)
Unaltered CD source.
17. Comfortably Numb (23th August - edited)
Unaltered CD source. The actual length of the song was shortened for CD and even more for LD by editing the guitar solo parts.
18. One Slip (23th August / composite - edited)
Unaltered US LD source.
19. Run Like Hell (23st August / - edited intro)
CD version of this song feature almost complete performance. Several delayed guitar licks in the intro were omitted.
LD version use one more delayed guitar lick in the intro, also there's a different ending with explosion from different night.
I made a decision to use CD source with additional guitar lick added from UK LD source.
Conclusion:
Now this version is about 15 minutes longer than the usual CD version and represents these concerts much better.
Note that the main aim of this edition is to merge all officially released Nassau Coliseum 1988 recordings into one expanded set.
So I didn't use other shows to restore missing tracks or edited pieces. It was done several years ago by other Pink Floyd enthusiasts...
voor al u muziek verzoeken http://poprock.actieforum.com/
Comments # 0